If you’re planning to create branded merchandise or promotional items, you’ve likely come across the terms custom pins and enamel pins. At first glance, they may seem like different products—but the reality is a bit more nuanced. Understanding the difference can help you choose the right option for your needs.
What Are Custom Pins?
Custom pins are a broad category of pins that are designed according to your specific requirements. They can include different materials, styles, and finishes such as:
- Enamel pins (soft or hard)
- Die-struck metal pins
- Printed pins
- Acrylic or wooden pins
In simple terms, custom pins refer to any pin made with your unique design, regardless of the material or style. They are highly flexible and can be tailored to suit branding, events, or personal projects.
What Are Enamel Pins?
Enamel pins are a specific type of custom pin that uses colored enamel (paint) to fill designs on a metal base. They are one of the most popular styles due to their vibrant look and durability.
There are two main types:
- Soft enamel pins: Textured surface with raised metal edges, more affordable
- Hard enamel pins: Smooth, polished finish, more premium and durable
Enamel pins are widely used for branding, collectibles, and fashion accessories because of their professional appearance and long-lasting quality.
Key Differences at a Glance
| Feature | Custom Pins | Enamel Pins |
| Definition | Broad category (all pin types) | Specific type of custom pin |
| Materials | Metal, acrylic, wood, etc. | Metal + enamel coating |
| Design Options | Very wide (multiple styles) | Focused on colored enamel designs |
| Cost Range | Varies widely | Usually mid-range (soft enamel cheaper) |
| Finish | Depends on style | Glossy, vibrant, premium look |
The Truth: They’re Not Really Competitors
Here’s the most important point:
Enamel pins are actually a type of custom pin—not a separate alternative.
Think of it like this:
- Custom pins = the category
- Enamel pins = one of the most popular choices within that category
In fact, many manufacturers use the terms interchangeably because enamel pins are the most commonly ordered custom pins.
Even online discussions reflect this confusion:
“Most lapel pins are enamel pins… the terms are often used the same.”
When Should You Choose Custom Pins?
Choose custom pins (non-enamel types) if you want:
1. Unique Materials
If you’re looking for something different—like wooden or acrylic pins—custom pins give you more variety.
2. Budget Flexibility
Some styles (like printed or acrylic pins) can be cheaper than enamel, especially for small orders.
3. Complex Artwork
Printed pins are better for highly detailed designs, gradients, or photo-like images.
4. Special Effects
Options like 3D molding, cutouts, or unusual shapes are easier with certain custom pin styles.
When Should You Choose Enamel Pins?
Choose enamel pins if you want:
1. Professional Look
Enamel pins have a polished, high-quality finish that works great for branding.
2. Durability
They are made from metal and baked enamel, making them long-lasting and resistant to wear.
3. Vibrant Colors
The enamel filling creates bold, eye-catching colors that stand out.
4. Popular Appeal
Enamel pins are trendy, collectible, and widely loved by customers and fans.
See also: Growing Your Business? Here’s How Bookkeeping Services Help
Cost Comparison
- Soft enamel pins: Most affordable enamel option (great for promotions)
- Hard enamel pins: More expensive but premium quality
- Other custom pins (acrylic/printed): Often cheaper for small runs
Bulk ordering significantly reduces the cost per unit for all types.
Which One Is Best for You?
The right choice depends on your goal:
- For branding & professional use → Go with enamel pins
- For creative or artistic designs → Consider printed or acrylic custom pins
- For budget-friendly promotions → Soft enamel or basic custom styles
- For premium merchandise → Hard enamel pins
Final Thoughts
Choosing between custom pins and enamel pins isn’t really about picking one over the other—it’s about understanding that enamel pins are part of the custom pin family.
If you want versatility and creative freedom, custom pins give you endless options. But if you’re aiming for a proven, high-quality, and visually appealing product, enamel pins are often the best choice.
In most cases, businesses and creators end up choosing enamel pins because they strike the perfect balance between cost, durability, and design impact. However, exploring other custom pin styles can help you stand out even more.
Ultimately, the best choice is the one that aligns with your brand, budget, and audience.
